The High Court of Kenya sitting in Migori has issued far-reaching orders regulating police operations in Nyatike Sub-County, in a landmark move aimed at safeguarding constitutional rights and curbing alleged abuses by security agencies.
In the case Francis Otieno Manyaki vs State Law Office and Inspector General of Police (HCCHRPET/E008/2026), presided over by Justice Anne Ong’injo, the court directed that all police operations within Nyatike—including those conducted by specialized units such as the General Service Unit (GSU)—must strictly adhere to the Constitution and established legal frameworks.
“The High Court has issued an order directing the Respondents to ensure that all police operations—including those by the GSU—within the areas of Macalder and adjacent locations in Nyatike Sub-County must be conducted strictly in accordance with the Constitution and the relevant laws of Kenya, and only on the basis of individualised investigations and identifiable suspects.”
The directive arises amid heightened tensions in the gold-rich belt of Nyatike, particularly in areas such as Macalder, where residents have reported cases of alleged harassment, arbitrary arrests, and heavy-handed security crackdowns following unrest linked to artisanal mining activities.
Key Court Orders
In her ruling delivered on March 27, 2026, Justice Ong’injo outlined several critical directives:
Police operations must be intelligence-led and targeted, based solely on identifiable suspects.
Respondents, including the Office of the Inspector General, have 21 days to file responses to the petition.
Applicants are granted leave to file further affidavits within 14 days upon service.
The matter will be mentioned on May 11, 2026, to confirm compliance and provide further directions.The court further warned that any disobedience of the orders would attract penal consequences.
End of Blanket Crackdowns
Legal experts interpret the ruling as a significant step toward ending indiscriminate security operations in the region.
“This effectively means that random, blanket, or group-based harassment, round-ups, and intimidation of residents in Macalder and surrounding areas are no longer lawful and have been stopped by the courts’ directive.”
The decision is expected to bring relief to residents who have long decried what they describe as collective punishment during security sweeps.
Community Reaction
The ruling has been welcomed by local leaders and residents, who see it as a victory for the rule of law and human rights.
Robley Ngoje, who has been at the forefront of advocating for justice in the region, was lauded for pursuing lawful avenues to address the grievances of Nyatike residents.
A resident of Nyatike, Peter, expressed relief following the court’s intervention:
“For a long time, innocent people here in Macalder have lived in fear of arbitrary arrests and harassment. This court order restores our dignity and gives us hope. Thank you Hon. Robley Ngoje for taking lawful action to stop harassment of the people of Nyatike,” one of the residents noted.
Background
Nyatike Sub-County in Migori County is known for its extensive artisanal gold mining activities, which have occasionally triggered disputes, protests, and subsequent security interventions.
In recent months, operations by police and paramilitary units have drawn criticism from human rights defenders and local leaders, who accuse authorities of using excessive force and targeting entire communities rather than specific suspects.
The petition filed before the High Court sought to challenge these practices, arguing that they violated fundamental rights including protection from arbitrary arrest, dignity, and due process as enshrined in the Constitution of Kenya.
Way Forward
The upcoming mention of the case in May will be crucial in determining whether security agencies have complied with the court’s directives. Observers note that the ruling sets an important precedent for policing standards not only in Nyatike but across other regions experiencing similar security challenges.
As the legal process continues, residents and stakeholders alike will be watching closely to see whether the orders translate into tangible changes on the ground.
About the Author
